Wildlife

Excerpt from The Courage of Birds: And the Often Surprising Ways They Survive Winter

Award-winning birder and acclaimed writer Pete Dunne explores how birds in North America have adapted to survive the challenges of the winter season 

  • Oct 28, 2024
  • 1,715 words
  • 7 minutes
(Illustration: David Allen Sibley; Photo: Kevin Karlson)
Expand Image
Advertisement
Advertisement

The following is an excerpt from Pete Dunne’s new book The Courage of Birds (Chelsea Green Publishing October 2024) and is printed with permission from the publisher.

Bird Feeding: A National Pastime

One of the most significant recent impacts upon winter bird distribution and survival has to do with the proliferation of backyard bird feeders. Since the early mid-twentieth century, the number of households maintaining bird feeding stations for wild birds has exploded, with over fifty million US and Canadian households, now maintaining one or more feeders (with four to ten feeders per yard being average). The hobby of bird feeding goes back to Thoreau (1854) and American writer Mable Osgood Wright (1885), but the popular pastime proliferated after World War II as Americans began moving to the suburbs, a new hybrid, bird-rich environment boasting an array of vegetation that birds find attractive, including shade trees, shrubbery, and flowering bushes like roses and forsythia.

Blue jay. (Illustration: David Allen Sibley)
Expand Image

As these suburban plants grow and mature, they turn ordinary suburban yards into de facto aviaries with commercial bird feeders acting as fruiting bodies. Today, feeding birds in your yard is only slightly less suburban-centric than maintaining a fine lawn or buying Girl Scout cookies from your neighbour. And while the activity does cut into a family budget, most homeowners are able to set aside the funds needed to offer their feathered minions one or more seed types, plus suet (beef fat) for more finicky feeders (and even meal worms for wrens and mimids). Multiple bird-feeding store chains have evolved to serve the needs of the bird-feeding market, as well as garden centres and agricultural feed stores that have expanded their inventories to include bird feeders and seed. Even grocery stores and hardware stores have capitalized upon the craze, offering consumers a selection of mixed or specialty seeds, plus the specialized feeders needed to dispense them. It is estimated that a billion pounds of seed are sold annually in the US and Canada, generating $4 billion in income. This sum is twice the income generated by the annual sale of comic books.

The proliferation of feeders has prompted many once-woodland birds to relocate, fully or in part, to the suburbs. Feeders concentrate birds that would otherwise distribute themselves more widely. It may even have induced some species to winter north of their historic range. It has been suggested, for example, that a number of bird-hunting Sharp-shinned Hawks may, now, be short-stopping their southern migration in response to the concentrated abundance of prey they find farther north. With songbirds abundant in suburban New England, there is scant need for this bird-hunting raptor to migrate on to the Middle Atlantic and southern states. And while both the overall and secondary impacts of backyard bird feeding remain largely unstudied, it is clear that seed-eating birds choose to concentrate where feeders are available. And compared to bird species that are not attracted to bird feeders, the populations of feeder birds are mostly stable, while many other songbird species are declining. It is possible, too, that backyard bird feeding has facilitated the northward range expansion of once-southern seed-eating species, like the Tufted Titmouse, Northern Cardinal, and Red-bellied Woodpecker. Their ranges, once stopping short of New England, have, since the mid-century, expanded even into Maine. Certainly, climate change is this northern expansion’s primary driver, but a reliable food resource would be a welcome support vehicle for pioneering species willing to leapfrog north, backyard feeder to backyard feeder.

Black-capped chickadee. (Illustration: David Allen Sibley)
Expand Image

But bird feeding’s greatest impact is likely upon human practitioners, who quickly develop a fascination with their feathered minions, nudging many people toward a greater bird-consciousness, which translates into support for open space and for politicians who advocate on behalf of bird and habitat protection.

Bird feeding is supplemental to the diets of birds that will continue to draw much of their nutritional needs from natural food stocks (including those natural plantings found in your yard). And the number of birds attending feeders vary year to year, with winters marked by finch irruptions, finding feeders brimming with thistle-seed-loving redpolls and Pine Siskins, and Evening Grosbeaks, whose appetite for sunflower seeds can quickly demolish a modest seed budget and has earned the large, bulbous-billed finches the nickname “Evening Grosspig.” But even in a normal (nonirruptive) year, our four South Jersey feeders serve approximately 140 individual birds per day, including the two Cooper’s Hawks and lone Sharp-shinned that are attracted not to the seed but the birds coming to our feeders. I estimate that my in-law’s Central Coast, California, home serves 150 birds per day, including the three Cooper’s Hawks and two Merlins that target her feeder regulars.

Estimating the total number of birds being served by bird feeders across North America is complicated by the fluidity among local birds—moving from one backyard to the next. A case in point, my cross-street neighbor boasts of the eight male cardinals in her yard. Some of these, at least, are part of the set of twelve males I count in our yard. But even presuming that she and I evenly split the 140 individual birds I attract to my feeders, that still leaves 70 individual birds per household in a non-irruption year, a figure I present as a baseline for feeding stations across North America. Multiplied by 50 million bird feeding stations, this comes to an astonishing 350 million birds being served by bird feeders, a fair percentage of the estimated 7.2 billion birds residing in the United States and Canada. Project FeederWatch, a bird-monitoring effort managed by Audubon and the Cornell Lab of Ornithology, projects a more conservative estimate: 9,110,689 individuals of 585 species (a figure established in 2011). This figure combines the estimates tabulated by homeowners participating in Project FeederWatch, who monitors birds at feeders across the United States and Canada. Not intended to calculate a total number of birds coming to feeders, Project FeederWatch strives, instead, to establish a standard methodology that can be used to monitor trends in bird numbers (not overall numbers). A worthy endeavour and one deserving of your participation.

Canada jay. (Illustration: David Allen Sibley)
Expand Image

Many authorities have compiled lists of common backyard birds. While these vary region to region, Ma Nature typically apportions representatives of basic family groups according to region. Thus, wherever you live, you probably find yourself within the range of one or more jay species. If you live in the west, you may find a scrub-jay, Steller’s Jay, or magpie. But east of the Rockies, the flamboyant Blue Jay is your neighbourhood jay unless you live in the boreal forest, where Canada Jays dominate, or the Rio Grande Valley, where the flamboyant Green Jay is your neighbourhood jay species.

No matter where you live, you can count on one or more chickadee or titmouse species to live near you. Mourning Doves and Downy Woodpeckers are near ubiquitous. Finches include the omnipresent House Finch, American Goldfinch and, in the west, the Lesser Goldfinch. Common sparrows include White-throated Sparrow, White-crowned Sparrow, and Dark-eyed Junco. And of course, the introduced but firmly established House Sparrow and European Starling occur just about everywhere we do. Significantly, all these species (and more) are drawn to backyard feeding stations. Mixing commercial seed (introduced in 1953) and other food items ensures bird numbers and diversity in your yard. And don’t forget water. Birds need water to drink and bathe, even in winter.

And while this book is not intended to be a how-to guide to bird feeding, a few simple tips will help homeowners attract more birds. First, understand the importance of trees and other cover. A bird feeder stuck in the middle of an open grass-covered yard, away from woody vegetation, will attract few birds, no matter how much food you offer. Feeder birds are mostly forest species that demand the safety afforded by woody vegetation to retreat into when hawks are prowling. No trees? A brush pile near your feeder will offer birds safe haven and a place to wait for perch space to open up. A pile of brush in your yard might not be in the landscaping style of Martha Stewart, but it does attract birds and you may find the latticework of branches constitutes the most popular bird gathering mechanism in your yard.

Snowy owl. (Illustration: David Allen Sibley)
Expand Image

Quality seed attracts more birds than mixes diluted with lots of cheap filler seed like cracked corn, canary seed, and milo and rape seed. Seed content is listed on the bag. What you want are mixes that offer a high percentage of black oil sunflower seed and millet. Pure black oil sunflower seed is consumed by all species and relished by many. We always offer at least one feeder dedicated solely to black oil sunflower seeds. Suet? Relished by many species. Shelled peanuts? Jays love them. Thistle? Sure to be a hit with goldfinches, and siskins treat the stuff like it was crack cocaine. If you have a nature centre or bird specialty store near you, stop in and get advice about food items and feeder types that work in your region. Keep feeders filled, especially during cold spells and on cold mornings and especially before birds go to roost (mid-afternoon). Winter birds need to go to roost with crops full, so afternoons are precisely when your feeder regulars will be counting on you the most.

While birds obviously elect to concentrate at feeders, the practice is not without risk. Concentrated birds facilitate the spread of bird-related illnesses, like avian flu, a risk mitigated by hunting hawks that serve as the guardians of your flock, culling sick individuals before they can infect healthy birds. Free-ranging house cats are also drawn to feeders, but unlike hawks, house cats are not natural predators. Small felines are not native to North America and are estimated to needlessly kill 2.4 billion birds per year, many of these at feeders. Cats are capable of six-foot vertical leaps, and they kill for pleasure, not because they are hungry. Keep cats indoors. It is why they are called “house cats.” And no, the bell collars don’t work. Cats quickly learn to move without ringing the bell.

Advertisement

Help us tell Canada’s story

You can support Canadian Geographic in 3 ways:

Related Content

A northern cardinal in a tree

Wildlife

7 ways to enjoy birds in your backyard this summer

You’ll be amazed at the feathered friends you can attract to your yard by following these simple tips

  • 1580 words
  • 7 minutes

Wildlife

Excerpt: The Bedside Book of Birds

Gorgeously illustrated and woven from centuries of human response to the delights of the feathered tribes, The Bedside Book of Birds is for everyone who is passionate about birds and all they mean to humanity

  • 768 words
  • 4 minutes
A male Canada warbler

Wildlife

How citizen scientists are helping to protect migratory birds

Conserving at-risk species is difficult when they’re constantly crossing international borders, but digital tools are making it easier than ever to track feathered globetrotters

  • 1383 words
  • 6 minutes

Wildlife

The magic in the mud: sandpipers’ migration superfood

An invisible fuel draws thousands of tiny migrating shorebirds to the Roberts Bank Mudflats each year. Now, we’re in danger of losing it forever. 

  • 3130 words
  • 13 minutes
Advertisement
Advertisement