Two geographers try to map Canada's true North

Defining where southern Canada ends and the North begins is trickier than it seems
  • Sep 22, 2016
  • 247 words
  • 1 minutes
mapping the north Expand Image

Let’s say you live in Flin Flon, Man. Or maybe Fort Vermilion, Alta. Or maybe even Whitehorse, Yukon. Would it surprise you to learn that you don’t actually live in the North? Well, not according to Chuck McNiven and Henry Puderer, anyway.

Instead, you live in an area called “North transition,” one of four regions the Statistics Canada geographers created (the others being “North,” “South transition” and “South”) in an attempt to determine exactly where Canada’s North is.

“To solve this cartographic brain teaser,” Mary Vincent wrote in the September/October 2000 Canadian Geographic story that explained McNiven and Puderer’s work, the two men “defined ‘northness’ using 16 characteristics, such as how often you have to flick on the furnace; the limits of permafrost, boreal forest, railways and all-season roads; number of agricultural growing days; climate; and accessibility to urban centres.”

The conclusion Vincent draws might cheer those who live in the North but discourage North transitioners, to coin an appellation for residents of that region. “And in Canada, it seems, it’s better to be on top of the country than in the middle. The North has huge hydroelectric facilities in Labrador and Quebec, extensive mining and jobs in territorial capitals and is less reliant on government sources of personal income than is any other part of the country. The North transition zone, on the other hand, emerges as Canada’s hidden have-not region, an area with few resources or urban centres.”


Related Content

Heinrich Scherer's 1702 chart of the North Pole

People & Culture

Why the North Pole matters: An important history of challenges and global fascination

In this essay, noted geologist and geophysicist Fred Roots explores the significance of the symbolic point at the top of the world. He submitted it to Canadian Geographic just before his death in October 2016 at age 93.

  • 5167 words
  • 21 minutes
The War of 1812 giant floor encourages students to interact with history


Giant floor maps put students on the map

Canadian Geographic Education’s series of giant floor maps gives students a colossal dose of cartography and is a powerful teaching tool

  • 1487 words
  • 6 minutes
The pumpjack is an iconic symbol of oil in the West.

Science & Tech

13+ things you didn’t know about energy

Massive oilfields, huge offshore rigs, high-tech refineries, colossal dams, sprawling wind farms — how much do you really know about BIG power in Canada?

  • 2842 words
  • 12 minutes


10 fascinating historic maps of the Arctic

  • 913 words
  • 4 minutes