This article is over 5 years old and may contain outdated information.


Let the quiet have its say

There are many ways to honour those who served and died in global conflicts, such as going to memorials — but perhaps it’s best to spend time there alone

  • Published Nov 11, 2018
  • Updated Oct 07, 2022
  • 717 words
  • 3 minutes
Canadian National Vimy Memorial monument with sheep grazing Expand Image

Michael Winter, who’s a friend of mine, is mostly known as a novelist, but it’s his not-novel Into the Blizzard that I’ve been re-reading this week as I travelled around northern France ahead of Sunday’s centenary observances of the 1918 Armistice that put an end to the First World War. Winter’s 2014 book is one of the best that I know about remembering and absorbing wars that other people fought a long time ago. “How can we be accurate about what happened, how can we be true to it?” is an apposite sentence you’ll come across in its pages. “And can war ever be declared over?”

Along with Winter’s questions, I’ve been weighing his advice — and, now, acting on it. There are many ways to honour those who served and those who died doing so: speeches and formal ceremonying are certainly some of them. Winter suggests going to memorials like the one at Beaumont-Hamel or Vimy the night before the politicians show up, if you can — spend some time there alone, let the quiet have its say.

And so, with Prime Minister Justin Trudeau scheduled to visit the Canadian National Vimy Memorial on Saturday, I spent my Friday going to not-Vimy on not-the-day-the-PM-went.

Officially, Farbus and Vimy are neighbouring villages, but the fact is they run almost together. If you leave Vimy’s cemetery and take three steps to your left, you’re in Farbus. I’d been reading about the battle there during the Vimy campaign, and looking at photographs showing how the village was all but obliterated when Canadian troops finished capturing it in April of 1917. There are no buildings in these photographs, only ruins of ruins, and smashed trees; I wouldn’t be surprised to learn that no brick survived that battle intact, and not a single leaf.

Today, Farbus is hearteningly unshattered, rebuilt long ago to look like a village that never saw a war roar through it, as bustling as it wants to be — or not at all, as was the case when I showed up. I parked by the church of St. Ranulphe and walked up Rue de la Paix and in behind the school (it seemed to be a holiday) and up the hill in back to see if I could find a commanding view. I couldn’t; the trees of Farbus are too many.

In Farbus, a town neighbouring Vimy that was all but obliterated by fighting in the First World War, Jean-Claude spent Saturday afternoon cleaning the memorial by the church in preparation for Sunday ceremonies. (Photo: Stephen Smith)
Expand Image
Vimy monument candlelight
The Canadian National Vimy Memorial is lit by candles, with a guard of honour at the stone sarcophagus at the memorial’s base. (Photo: Stephen Smith)
Expand Image

On the way back I stopped to talk to the only person I saw. Jean-Claude was scrubbing a broomhead over the buttery-coloured stone of one of the village’s memorials ahead of the weekend’s ceremonies. We talked about the Canadians in 1917 — my broken French kept the conversation to simple statements bolstered on both sides by enthusiastic nods. “We’ll be ready for Sunday,” he said, as if he thought I might have been sent to judge his scrubbing. The mayor had just died, he confided; they’d only just buried him. Now it was up to the regional government to decide what to do about replacing him. I gave him my okay — that seemed for the best.  

I did eventually get to the Vimy Memorial, later. Park staff and Canadian soldiers were busy preparing for a pre-prime ministerial evening program involving Army bands and honour guards and a light show. But those were still a couple of hours away. I spent some time just trying to take in the magnificence of Walter Allward’s monument, and to balance the beauty here with the scale of the suffering that’s represented. There are 11,285 names etched in the limestone at Vimy that belong to Canadians killed in France whose final resting place remains unknown. I didn’t know what to say about that then, and I don’t now. I walked around the monument a couple of times, maybe more. The sun was high, Friday, and the blue of the sky up there looked like it might crack if you touched it, or departed this place without having made the effort to read every one of those names aloud.


Are you passionate about Canadian geography?

You can support Canadian Geographic in 3 ways:

Related Content

St. Symphorien Cemetery, east of Mons, was established by the German Army in 1914 after the opening salvoes of the First World War. Private John Parr, the first British soldier to be killed on the Western Front, is buried here. So too is Private George Price, from Falmouth, Nova Scotia, who’s recognized as the last soldier of the British Empire to die in the First World War — at 10:58 on the morning of November 11, 1918. St. Symphorien contains the graves of 284 German soldiers along with 227 British, and t


Time and the war

Roaming First World War sites and cemeteries in northern France and Belgium, Stephen Smith reflects on what time heals — and what it can’t 

  • 1150 words
  • 5 minutes
A tribute placed at the Vimy Memorial


The next 100 years

Now that a century has passed since the end of the First World War, is it inevitable that efforts to remember the events of the war will start to fade?

  • 1029 words
  • 5 minutes

People & Culture

Renewed Remembrance: Marking 70 years since the Korean War Armistice

On July 27, 1953, an armistice was signed ending the bloodshed of the Korean War — if not the war itself — but questions have since been raised surrounding the conflict’s remembrance in Canada and beyond

  • 1158 words
  • 5 minutes
Gordon Hempton records audio in Grasslands National Park

Science & Tech

The sounds of silence 

A sound artist listens for quiet in Grasslands National Park

  • 5035 words
  • 21 minutes