This article is over 5 years old and may contain outdated information.


Whales under threat in noisy Atlantic waters

The Committee on the Status of Endangered Wildlife in Canada has assessed three whale species as being at risk from increased ship traffic

  • Published May 07, 2019
  • Updated Mar 09, 2022
  • 820 words
  • 4 minutes
A fin whale Expand Image

Three whale species face increasing threats from noise and ship traffic in Canadian waters, according to the Committee on the Status of Endangered Wildlife in Canada (COSEWIC). At its most recent semi-annual meeting, COSEWIC assessed new data on sei, fin and Sowerby’s beaked whales and determined all face some level of conservation risk in the Atlantic and Pacific oceans.

Particularly, COSEWIC recommended that sei whales in the Atlantic Ocean be listed as endangered, meaning they face imminent extinction in their local habitat. Previously, not enough data was available to assess their risk of extinction. Sei whales in the Pacific Ocean have been listed as endangered under the federal Species at Risk Act (SARA) since 2005.

“The sei whales in the Atlantic used to be data deficient, which meant we really didn’t know,” says Hal Whitehead, co-chair of the COSEWIC Marine Mammals Specialist Subcommittee and a biology professor at Dalhousie University in Halifax. “We have enough information now to say these guys should be endangered, too.”

COSEWIC is an independent advisory board that assesses the conservation status of wildlife species in Canada, but species receive no formal protection under SARA until the federal environment minister acts on the committee’s recommendations.

The committee also assessed the fast-swimming fin whales as being of special concern in both Atlantic and Pacific waters, meaning they are at risk of becoming threatened or endangered. In the Pacific, however, this assessment represented an improvement in the whales’ conservation status.

“Fin whales in the Pacific used to be threatened, so we are a bit more optimistic … than we were 10 years ago,” says Whitehead.

John Reynolds, chair of COSEWIC and an aquatic ecology professor at B.C.’s Simon Fraser University, says that while whales are hard to count, researchers have been seeing greater numbers of fin whales in Pacific U.S. waters and hope to see the same in Canadian waters soon.

In the Atlantic, Sowerby’s beaked whales remain of special concern, a status they’ve held since 2006 largely as a result of commercial whaling. These whales often die as a result of beaching. The reason for this is uncertain, but Reynolds says noise from ship traffic could be a factor.

“You combine all the marine traffic with seismic activity [for oil and gas exploration] and it does look like the Atlantic Ocean is getting a lot busier and a lot more noisy,” he says. “I’m not surprised an animal [that] is sensitive to noise is having trouble recovering from a history of whaling.”

Noisier oceans have experts concerned

Sei, fin, and Sowerby’s beaked whales all evolved in oceans quieter than those today, according to Reynolds.

Sowerby’s beaked whales are especially sensitive to noise pollution, having evolved in deeper waters far from the coast. They use echolocation for daily functions such as hunting, socializing, and navigation. Noise from large ships, naval training operations, and oil and gas exploration disrupt these functions. In recent years, these activities have ramped up in the Atlantic Ocean.

“It’s not just direct ship strikes that are a problem,” says Reynolds. “There’s entanglement in fishing gear, there’s noise, there’s disturbance.”

Map showing ship traffic across the North Atlantic Ocean for 2016-17 Expand Image
This map shows the density of marine vessel traffic in the North Atlantic for 2016-2017. Map taken from MarineTraffic ( (Map: CNW Group/Committee on the Status of Endangered Wildlife in Canada)

New MPA regulations a positive step

Whitehead says marine protected areas (MPAs) — offshore or coastal areas set aside specifically for conservation purposes — can provide whales with a refuge from noise pollution, pointing to the Gully MPA off Nova Scotia as an example. It was designated as an MPA in 2004.

“I’ve been working at the Gully for 30 years, and in the first 15 we worked there, we hardly saw [Sowerby’s beaked whales], and if we did, it was a huge event,” says Whitehead. “In the last 15 years, they’ve become pretty common. It’s lovely.”

However, he notes that the increased whale sightings are not necessarily the result of population growth, since the whales don’t give birth that often.

“My thinking is that they range around and are very sensitive to underwater noise … and now that [the Gully’s] grown quieter than other parts of their range, they’ve come there and liked it.”

Whitehead is optimistic that sweeping prohibitions on industrial activity within MPAs announced last month will go a long way toward ensuring these areas fulfill their purpose.

Reynolds agrees, adding MPAs benefit aquatic ecosystems as a whole.

“Trying to give some safe haven not only for whales but also for fish and other marine life is a very good idea indeed.”

Related: Canada announces ban on industrial activities in marine protected areas


Are you passionate about Canadian geography?

You can support Canadian Geographic in 3 ways:

Related Content


Punctuation’s mark: Can we save the critically endangered North Atlantic right whale?

After a series of mass deaths in recent years, what can we do?

  • 4110 words
  • 17 minutes
Ten years after the release of her seminal book Sea Sick, Alanna Mitchell again plumbs the depths of the latest research on the health of the world’s oceans — and comes up gasping


“There’s no coming back from this:” Why the global ocean crisis threatens us all

Ten years after the release of her seminal book Sea Sick, Alanna Mitchell again plumbs the depths of the latest research on the health of the world’s oceans — and comes up gasping

  • 4426 words
  • 18 minutes


9 ocean stories to mark the UN Decade of Ocean Science

The United Nations Decade of Ocean Science kicks off Feb. 3, 2021

  • 1103 words
  • 5 minutes


Beluga whistles and clicks could be silenced by an increasingly noisy Arctic Ocean

Sound is an integral part of a beluga’s life, so the quality of the underwater acoustic environment is very important for the health and survival of belugas

  • 940 words
  • 4 minutes