Mapping

Marine protected areas in Canada may not be as protected as we think

Marine protected areas are widely considered to be an effective tool for ocean conservation. But are they living up to their full potential? 

A photo of Arctic Bay in Nunavut; Canada's Arctic Ocean is home to four marine protected areas, including the Tuvaijuittuq Marine Protected Area off the coast of Ellesmere Island. (Photo: Isaac Demeester/Unsplash)
Expand Image

Protecting 30 by 30: that’s the goal. Canada aims to safeguard 30 per cent of its oceans by 2030 to reverse biodiversity loss, protect ecosystems and ensure resilience against warming and acidification. But how can we conserve something as dynamic, deep, multi dimensional and diverse as the ocean?

Globally, marine protected areas are considered an effective tool in ocean conservation. There are 14 in Canada protected under the federal Oceans Act, in addition to national marine conservation areas and marine national wildlife areas. These fall under the jurisdiction of Fisheries and Oceans Canada, Parks Canada, and Environment and Climate Change Canada, respectively. And they’re protected by various bits of legislation, including the Oceans Act, the Fisheries Act and the Canada Wildlife Act. “There are multiple partners and stakeholders who are involved within the ocean space,” says Kathy Graham, director general of marine planning and conservation at Fisheries and Oceans Canada. “It’s a delicate dance.”

But what do current ocean protections look like? Last fall, the Canadian Parks and Wilderness Society (CPAWS) released a report on the effectiveness of 18 sites covering about 8.3 per cent of Canada’s ocean estate. The findings were worrying: based on the activities allowed to take place in them, “seven MPAs are strongly protected, eight are weakly protected, and two are incompatible with biodiversity conservation,” the report concluded. You can see these designations on the map. The seven areas that were assessed as “strongly protected” make up just 0.4 per cent of Canada’s oceans — a far cry from what is, on the surface, “protected.”

That’s not to say that efforts aren’t being made to enhance Canada’s marine protected areas; in 2019, the federal government adopted protection standards for all new MPAs that prohibit four industrial activities: oil and gas, mining, dumping and bottom trawling. These standards don’t yet apply to previously established marine protected areas, but the government has committed to assess whether the prohibited activities “actually contravene the conservation objectives [of existing MPAs],” says Graham. “When you implement a new standard, you look forward, predominantly, at the outset, but we have committed to actually doing that as part of the management cycle.”

While effective protection for 30 per cent of Canada’s oceans is complicated, says Alexandra Barron, who co-wrote the report, “implementing minimum protection standards provides a baseline of protection — and also a baseline of coordination across departments — that will ensure that we don’t have these horrifically harmful activities.”

Protected areas data: Canadian Protected and Conserved Areas Database, 2021. Protected areas status: MPA Monitor: Assessing Canada's marine protected areas, Canadian Parks and Wilderness Society, 2021; Rithikha Rajamohan. (Map: Chris Brackley/Can Geo)
Expand Image
Advertisement

This story is from the May/June 2022 Issue

Related Content

Three long-finned pilot whales swim in a cerulean blue sea

Environment

Canada announces ban on industrial activities in marine protected areas

Oil and gas extraction, mining, dumping among prohibited activities in ecologically sensitive areas set aside for conservation

  • 848 words
  • 4 minutes
Ten years after the release of her seminal book Sea Sick, Alanna Mitchell again plumbs the depths of the latest research on the health of the world’s oceans — and comes up gasping

Environment

“There’s no coming back from this:” Why the global ocean crisis threatens us all

Ten years after the release of her seminal book Sea Sick, Alanna Mitchell again plumbs the depths of the latest research on the health of the world’s oceans — and comes up gasping

  • 4426 words
  • 18 minutes

Environment

The sixth extinction

The planet is in the midst of drastic biodiversity loss that some experts think may be the next great species die-off. How did we get here and what can be done about it?

  • 4869 words
  • 20 minutes
sea star disease the blob

Environment

2019 was the warmest year on record for the world’s oceans. What does that mean for Canada?

Acidification, disruptions to food webs among the biggest concerns for ocean scientists

  • 933 words
  • 4 minutes